Eva Carlston Academy Examines the Toxic Nature of Social Media for Teens

Eva Carlston Academy Examines the Toxic Nature of Social Media for Teens


Within the past two decades, social media platforms, such as Facebook and Instagram, have become defining aspects of modern culture and a major influence on the younger generations of Americans. On average, popular social media apps like Instagram and Facebook receive more than 1.5 billion users daily, with a significant portion of these users between the ages of 12 to 17. According to one Pew Research survey, an estimated 63% of teens say they use at least one social media platform every day, while 45% of teens report being on the internet “almost constantly.” For many teenagers, social media has become an almost addictive activity, and for good reason.

Scientists now know that overuse of social media creates brain stimulation patterns similar to patterns formed by other addictive behaviors. The brain responds to social media in a similar way to other rewards and releases dopamine when a user’s post is well received by followers and gets “likes, shares, and positive comments.” This has led to a generation of young Americans who are highly active on social media and reliant on these apps for social interactions. However, the question remains, are there long-lasting repercussions for teens’ daily use of social media?

As a leader in adolescent education, Eva Carlston Academy knows firsthand the prevalence of social media in teens’ lives and the degree to which social media can affect adolescent mental health. While social media has become a significant aspect of our digital age, Eva Carlston Academy stresses the importance of parental education on the risks associated with social media overuse. Below, Eva Carlston Academy reviews some of the ways social media poses the greatest risks for teen mental and physical health.

Increased Risk of Depression

Within the past ten years, researchers have found a strong connection between the rise of teen depression and social media. Between 2005 and 2017, when social media usage grew exponentially, teen cases of major depression rose from just 8.7 percent to 13.2 percent, an increase of nearly 52 percent. As more research has been conducted on the risks of frequent social media use, researchers have found a strong correlation between teen’s daily social media use and a decrease in social activity, increased loneliness, and various symptoms of depression. Teens who “unplugged” and did not show daily activity on social media sites were far less likely to report mental health issues than their peers with significant screen use. Furthermore, researchers now know that social media disproportionally affects females.

Although research has shown that girls and boys who frequently use social media will report greater instances of depression, with teen girls, these instances appear at a greater rate. One study found that 15% of teen girls who spent 30 minutes a day on social media were unhappy, while 26% of girls who spent 6+ hours on social media reported depression while only 11 and 18 of teen boys, respectively, showed depression for the same amount of time spent on social media apps. Why are teen girls more prone to depression when using social media? Research has shown that teen girl’s self-esteem is formed to a greater degree by positive social interactions and popularity than their male counterparts. Eva Carlston states that social media is an analytical arbiter of social status where popularity is determined by likes and followers. As such, social media can have a severe negative impact on teen girl mental health.

Promotion of Youth Social Comparison

One of the most significant ways social media wears away at teen mental health is by promoting social comparison. Adolescent years (between the ages of 11 to 18) are a formative period where young adults often prioritize social standing and use social currency to form their self-worth. Social psychology has found teens are highly susceptible to social comparison because they are looking for ways to establish an identity that will be viewed as valuable by their community. Social media allows teens to directly view what characteristics are celebrated in our culture and how “popular” individuals depict themselves online. Teens who typically spend six hours a day on social media are barraged with constant social comparison of their peers, which often leads to self-esteem and body image issues and increased instances of depression and anxiety. This can be seen in a recent Pew Research Center report, where 26 percent of teens said that social media sites make them feel worse about themselves and their own lives.

Sleep Deprivation

As social media platforms are designed to keep users on their page for hours in an “endless scroll,” many teens are highly susceptible to the addictive nature of social media. Oftentimes, this can result in teens prioritizing social media over valuable sleep. Insomnia can be highly impactful on a teen’s daily life, as frequent sleep loss can lead to poor academic performance, increased moodiness, overeating, and worsen existing mental health problems such as anxiety, depression, and ADD.

Additionally, the blue light that comes from computers and laptops has been found to interfere with our natural circadian rhythms. Blue light stimulates the part of the brain that keeps people alert and energized, keeping electronic users awake for long hours and increasing the likelihood of waking up later in the night. According to a British study of 900 teens between the ages of 12 to 15, one-fifth of study participants said they are restless during bedtime and never fully fall asleep. Many teens report a fear of “missing out” and, as a result, are likely to wake up and check social media throughout the night.